Robert Baratheon or Viserys Targaryen?

Rate this post

Each Sport of Thrones and Home of the Dragon analyze what it means to be a very good chief. Is benefit one thing that’s decided by future, or can anybody rise throughout the ranks to develop into the ruler of the Seven Kingdoms? We see all through each reveals that the Iron Throne has a corrupting affect on people who sit upon it. The attract of energy is typically unimaginable to withstand, and solely a clever chief can put aside their temptations. One of many causes that the Sport of Thrones finale, “The Iron Throne,” was so closely criticized was that it didn’t present why Brandon Stark (Isaac Hempstead Wright) was worthy of being named King. Did “Bran the Damaged” actually have the best story out of all of the Sport of Thrones characters?


We see two very several types of Kings within the first seasons of Sport of Thrones and Home of the Dragon. Robert Baratheon (Mark Addy) has no declare primarily based upon his birthright; he took the place for himself after serving to Ned Stark (Sean Bean) wage struggle in opposition to “The Mad King” Aerys II Targaryen. Robert has virtually no real interest in being King, which is maybe for the higher. Nevertheless, Viserys Targaryen I (Paddy Considine) inherits the throne after being elected because the successor to his grandfather, King Jaehaerys I Targaryen. Viserys has been privileged for his whole life, and has by no means needed to combat for the throne in the identical approach that Robert did.

Each leaders have their deserves. Robert represents the “folks’s King,” as he needed to take the crown with a purpose to stop a bigger bloodbath from a tyrant. Nevertheless, the accountability of rulership isn’t one which he may reside as much as, and Robert units the stage for the Seven Kingdoms to fall into chaos when questions are raised in regards to the legitimacy of his son, Joffrey (Jack Gleeson). Viserys could have been ignorant in some ways, however he is aware of the significance of naming his daughter, Rhaenyra (Milly Alcock and Emma D’Arcy) as inheritor. He tries to proceed the Targaryen dynasty as a peaceable one, as he is aware of the accountability that they’re burdened with as a result of A Track Of Ice And Fireplace prophecy. Neither character is an ideal King or man, however Viserys proves to be the higher chief throughout his reign.

Viserys Chooses Peace, Robert’s Reign Begins With Warfare

Robert’s reign was initiated by a riot, however he managed to maintain a relative sense of peace following the dying of “The Mad King.” Robert no less than realizes that Ned will have the ability to serve the realm finest by remaining Warden of the North. Nevertheless, Robert has allowed Viserys (Harry Lloyd) and Daenerys (Emilia Clarke) to stay alive. Figuring out that one of many former King’s kids may threaten his rule, Robert makes the short-sighted choice to stage an assassination. This breaks his bond with Ned and finally ends up rising Daenerys’ need to take again her birthright.

Comparatively, Viserys’ reign is one in every of peace and relative prosperity. Though his predecessor did the exhausting work of stopping a riot from the Religion Militant, Viserys does his finest to not ruffle anybody’s feathers. Though he’s blind to the state of affairs within the Stepstones, Viserys in the end manages the state of affairs by making peace with each his brother, Daemon (Matt Smith), and the Lord of Driftmark, Corlys Velaryon (Steve Toussaint).

Viserys understands that having a professional inheritor is crucial. His selection to call Rhaenrya as an alternative of Daemon could have been predicated by his brother’s insult, however Viserys is aware of that Daemon is simply too inherently unstable to take a seat on the Iron Throne. By naming Rhaenyra throughout her adolescence, he permits his daughter to study in regards to the historical past of her household and attend crucial small council conferences. Robert doesn’t even cease to consider the ramifications of his affairs if any of the illegitimate kids he’s fathered ever discovered about their bloodline, and he by no means appears to query why his sadistic son has blonde hair.

RELATED: ‘Home of the Dragon’: Jason Concepcion on Rhaenyra and Alicent’s Decaying Friendship

Viserys Takes His Place as King Critically

Regardless that Robert took management of the dominion to finish a tyrannical monarch, he did nothing to vary the programs of presidency that have been in place. Whether or not this was out of greed or laziness, Robert primarily put the Baratheon bloodline on the middle of Westerosi politics. He makes the error of preserving shut firm with the Lannisters. Robert is oblivious to the true motivations of his spouse, Cersei (Lena Headey); he additionally fails to understand she’s having an affair together with her brother, Jaime (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau), and that none of their kids are professional.

Comparatively, Viserys is nicely conscious of why his bloodline is in management; they’re burdened with data of the A Track of Ice and Fireplace prophecy and tells Rhaenyra in regards to the tasks she is going to inherit. Viserys involves his daughter’s protection, even after the beginning of his son, Aegon II (Tom Glynn-Carney). Regardless that his marriage to Alicent Hightower (Emily Carey) offended the Velaryons, Viserys is ready to discover a peaceable answer by forming a wedding pact between his daughter and Laenor Velaryon (John Macmillan). It’s solely by the manipulation of Otto Hightower (Rhys Ifans) that his imaginative and prescient turns into corrupted.

In contrast to Robert, Viserys takes a tough have a look at his legacy. He needs to be remembered as a Nice King, and turns into extra reflective in his older years. Whereas Robert sees marriage and household as nothing past a political benefit, Viserys is genuinely delighted by his kinfolk. Some of the shifting sequences within the first season of Home of the Dragon is when an growing old Viserys attends a dinner along with his whole household in «The Lord of the Tides.»

Viserys Has Far Extra Integrity Than Robert

Robert has no beliefs that he sticks to. He embarrasses the realm along with his mood and affairs and is incited right into a rage by small quarrels. Even if Viserys causes a rift between his home and the Velaryons by not marrying Laena Velaryon (Nanna Blondell) and even if he appears extra content material to construct his mannequin of Valyria, Viserys is loyal to his household and to his spouse, and he is a continuing advocate for peaceable compromise. Whereas his temperament just isn’t at all times safe, Viserys is ready to forgive Daemon for his crimes and scold Alicent for her outburst of violence, even after affected by his illness, he is ready to come to his daughter’s protection when he’s known as to it.

Each of those Kings’ reigns lay the groundwork for civil struggle, however maybe any system of presidency tied so intently to at least one bloodline is certain to fall into battle, and struggle could at all times be inevitable in Westeros. Viserys understands this and commits his remaining efforts to attempting to maintain the peace inside his household. Viserys dies believing he has fashioned a peaceable bond between the 2 halves of his household and has executed what is correct for the realm. Whereas Robert’s dying incites “The Warfare of 5 Kings,” and he does little to ease the strain among the many opponents to the throne. He may need been a mighty warrior, however Robert was not made to rule.


Por favor ingrese su comentario!
Por favor ingrese su nombre aquí