Lebrecht Weekly | John Luther Adams: Sila, the breath of the world (cantaloupe)

Rate this post

Commercial / Publicité

This web page can also be accessible in / Cette web page est également disponible en:
Francais (French)

  • Person Rankings (1 Votes)


Typically I hearken to music as a public service: simply so that you don’t should. The US composer John Luther Adams has a excessive popularity for ecologically descriptive music of meditative extrospection. His orchestral suite Turn out to be Ocean gained a 2014 Pulitzer Prize and topped the classical charts for a few weeks. It bought to the purpose that the world-famous Nixon in China composer John Adams needed to go round telling individuals he was not that Adams.

Myself, I appreciated his suite. It occupied a vacant house someplace between John Cage and Greta Thunberg. It was agreeable and very nicely written for full orchestra and I seemed ahead to what John Luther Adams would possibly do subsequent.

Commercial / Publicité

If that is it, I’m accomplished. Sila, we’re informed, represents ‘the wind and the climate, the forces of nature’. It’s scored for 5 ensembles of 16 musicians, ‘dispersed extensively, surrounding the listeners, who’re free to maneuver round and uncover their very own particular person listening factors’. A occurring, in different phrases. On document, it comes over as aural floss, various in dynamics however with out a lot flavour or detectable factors of curiosity. It has no formal starting or finish. Eternity, beside this, will appear brief.

If I would like wind and climate I shall open a window. If I would like music, I’ll give John Luther Adams a miss.

There’s one other worrying factor right here. 4 modern composers – Michael Gordon, David Lang, Kenny Savelson and Julia Wolfe – are listed on the document as government producers. This seems like a conspiracy of latest American composers in opposition to the listening public.


This web page can also be accessible in / Cette web page est également disponible en:
Francais (French)


Por favor ingrese su comentario!
Por favor ingrese su nombre aquí